I am on vacation this week, so let’s do something light and largely pointless. Let’s talk about sports. Specifically, let’s talk about my ideas to make them better.

First, let’s look at the two sports that overlap this time of year: the NCAA basketball tournament, and Major League Baseball.

For March Madness, here’s my idea: expand the NCAA tourney from 68 to 72 teams. I would then divide the 72 teams into 4 brackets (just like it is now), but I would then seed them 1 through 18. Before the big opening weekend of March Madness, I would have the 15 seed play the 18 seed, and the 16 play the 17. The winner of the 15/18 game would play the 2 seed in each bracket, and the winner of the 16/17 game would play the 1 seed. This does a number of good things (at least in my mind):

  1. Adds four teams to the tournament, which doesn’t dramatically change the makeup, but does allow one or two additional mid-major teams to get in the tourney, and show what they can do against teams that refuse to schedule them during the regular season.
  2. Doubles the number of “play-in” games, making each night more intriguing.
  3. It gives the lowest-seed teams a chance to actually win a tournament game. And, to make it more exciting, the NCAA could decide to let the 15 and 16 seeds host the play-in games. This would put these opening NCAA games on college campuses, increasing the interest and excitement.
  4. The NCAA makes more money. And as we all know, the NCAA likes making more money.

Ok, that’s NCAA basketball. I’m going to skip the NBA, because…well, because I just don’t care about the NBA.

So, on to baseball. I would expand the wild card game to a three-game series. Currently, the two wild card teams in each league (American and National) play a one-game, sudden-death, loser-go-home free-for-all. While that’s exciting, for sure, it takes a sport with 162 games, and forces four teams to prove their postseason worth in only one game. And if in that one game, you have to face a guy like Madison Bumgarner or Jake Arrieta, you’re likely toast.

So, why not make the wild card a three-game series? This has the benefit of replicating what the season actually is. The six-month baseball season can be broken down, essentially, into lots of little three-game seasons. And the best teams tackle the season by trying to win as many three-game series as they can.

So, carry this over into the wild card, with a slight twist — and a throwback to the old days: play the first two games of a three-game wild card as a doubleheader. So, if the team that hosts the doubleheader wins both games, they move on without having to try to win the wild card on the road. But, if the visiting team can win one of those 2, they have the chance to win the third game at home. Since it seems to me to be a coin flip which is better — hosting the doubleheader, or having the final game at home — both wild card teams essentially have access to home field opportunity.

In the end, this simple change would add excitement and money (something MLB enjoys, just like the NCAA) — all without adding any extra days to an already-inflated postseason calendar.

On to college football. I think it’s time to expand to an eight-team playoff. To pick those 8, I would give an automatic bid to the team that wins the championship of the 4 top conferences. The remaining 4 bids would go to 4 at-large teams — determined in the same way the 4 teams are now picked.

Why four automatic bids? Well, it’s because there are five power conferences, and by only giving an automatic bid to the four, it serves as motivation to the teams in the those conferences to schedule stronger games. Each conference will be ranked on the strength of its out-of-conference schedule, and since no conference will want to miss out on an automatic bid, they’ll play better games.

In short, I see it working this way: if a team is the champion of one of football’s four best conferences, it deserves an automatic bid — even if it stumbled in the regular season (I see you Penn State). But with four at-large bids, deserving teams that haven’t won their conference also have a shot. And if adding an additional playoff game is too much for college students (I say this with no sense of sarcasm), then go back to 11 regular-season games.

Okay, one more: the National Hockey League. For that, I only have one suggestion: Let every team into the playoffs. Every. Single. Team. And then have a really short, 30-game regular season. With the league going to 31 teams this fall, have each team play each other team once — and that’s it. Begin the playoffs at that point, since, really, that’s all that matters anyway. I mean, does anyone really pay attention to the NHL regular season (outside of Canada, I mean)?

So, that’s what I would do if I were Sports Czar. What would you do?



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s